Workplace Issues

Settlement Agreements.

Been offered a settlement agreement? You must take independent legal advice before you sign, usually paid for by your employer, and it's a chance to check the offer is fair and negotiate more.

Have a quick question? Skip to common questions
Settlement Agreements
About this service

How a settlement agreement works

A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract that ends a dispute, or your employment, on agreed terms. In return for a payment, and often an agreed reference, you give up the right to bring specified legal claims against your employer, such as unfair dismissal or discrimination. They are used in all sorts of situations: redundancy, a disciplinary or performance process, a restructure, or simply where the working relationship has broken down. For the agreement to be valid, you must take independent legal advice on it before you sign, and once signed the claims it covers cannot be pursued. ACAS explains how settlement agreements work.

Should you sign?

Signing is always voluntary, your employer cannot force you, and refusing is not, in itself, a reason to dismiss you. But a settlement agreement is often offered as part of a process that could otherwise end in dismissal, and it asks you to give up potentially valuable claims, so it deserves careful thought rather than a quick signature. The right question is not just whether the money looks reasonable, but whether it reflects the real strength of the claims you would be waiving. That is exactly what we are there to tell you.

Getting advice, usually at your employer’s expense

Independent legal advice is not optional, it is a legal requirement for a settlement agreement to validly waive your claims, and your adviser has to sign a certificate confirming it was given. The good news is that employers almost always contribute to the cost of that advice as part of the deal, so in a straightforward case it often costs you nothing. Your solicitor acts for you alone, whoever pays the bill, and will check the drafting actually does what it should before advising you to sign.

What can you negotiate?

A settlement agreement is a negotiation, even when it is presented as final. The payment, the tax treatment, the wording of your reference, the confidentiality terms and any post-termination restrictions can all be discussed, and employers generally expect some back-and-forth. Your leverage comes from the strength of the claims you would be giving up, the better your position, the more there is to negotiate. We will tell you which terms are standard, which are unusual, and where there is room to push, and we can handle the negotiation for you. New rules are also coming that will stop agreements being used to silence someone about harassment or discrimination.

How we help

We advise employees across South Wales and the South West on settlement agreements every week, explaining what you are signing, making sure the tax and the reference are right, and negotiating where the terms fall short. Most of the time the advice is covered by your employer’s contribution. Where a settlement follows a redundancy or a possible unfair or wrongful dismissal, we will tell you honestly how the offer compares with bringing a claim. To get your agreement reviewed, you can request a callback or contact our team.

A settlement agreement is a negotiation, not a fait accompli, we make sure the offer reflects what your claims are really worth.

Our approach
How we work

Clear advice. Practical next steps.

Every settlement agreements matter is different. We start by understanding your situation before we recommend an approach.

We won't push you toward a process that doesn't fit. We won't drag things out. And we'll always tell you what something will cost before we start it.

  • A dedicated specialist for your matter, backed by the wider Robertsons workplace issues team
  • Transparent pricing — clear written costs before any work begins
  • Plain-English advice — no jargon, no surprises
  • Offices across South Wales and the South West
How the process works

What to expect, step by step

1

The offer

Your employer proposes terms, often in a “without prejudice” conversation or letter.

2

Independent advice

We go through the agreement with you and explain exactly what you would be giving up, advice that's a legal requirement, and usually paid for by your employer.

3

Negotiation

Where the terms undervalue your position, we negotiate the payment, the reference and the wording on your behalf.

4

Signing

Once you're happy, we sign the adviser's certificate, the agreement takes effect, and your employer makes the agreed payment.

What settlement agreements clients say

Real stories from real clients

★★★★★
“Prompt and professional service, completed the scope of works with the most effective communication path. I can highly recommend their service.”
Colin Lewis Employment law
★★★★★
“Great service provided. Always helpful, courteous, friendly and efficient.”
Joffie Irvine
★★★★★
“Excellent, all round professional service. Clear, concise, helpful and personable.”
Darren
Common questions

Questions clients ask us about settlement agreements

Yes — settlement agreements frequently include an agreed reference, either as a full written reference or a factual confirmation of job title and dates of employment. Employers are not legally obliged to provide a reference in most circumstances, but agreeing one as part of the settlement is a valuable protection — it gives you certainty about what will be said to future employers. The agreed reference should be appended to the settlement agreement itself so there is no ambiguity about its contents. Where a dispute about the employee's performance or conduct has arisen, securing an agreed neutral reference can be as commercially important as the financial settlement.

Yes — a settlement agreement is a negotiation, not a take-it-or-leave-it offer, even if it is presented as one. The financial amount, the tax treatment of payments, the wording of any reference, the scope of confidentiality obligations, post-termination restrictions, and the timing of payment are all potentially negotiable. Your solicitor can advise on which terms are standard and which are unusual or unfavourable, and can negotiate on your behalf. Employers generally expect some negotiation, particularly on the financial terms. The strength of your underlying legal position — the claims you would be waiving — is the primary factor in determining your negotiating leverage.

No — signing a settlement agreement is always voluntary. Your employer cannot compel you to sign, and refusing to do so is not itself grounds for dismissal. However, the practical context matters: a settlement agreement is often offered as part of a process — redundancy, disciplinary, or performance management — that may result in dismissal if not resolved by agreement. Understanding your legal position before deciding whether to sign is essential. The agreement waives your right to bring the claims specified in it — potentially valuable claims — so the decision deserves careful consideration with independent legal advice, not a rushed signature.

There is no statutory minimum period for considering a settlement agreement, but the ACAS Code of Practice recommends a minimum of ten calendar days to consider the terms. Employers are expected to allow reasonable time, and pressure to sign immediately or within an unreasonably short period can be relevant to whether the agreement was entered into freely. In practice, most employers allow at least a week. If you feel pressured to sign more quickly than is reasonable, say so — and if necessary, ask your solicitor to request more time on your behalf. Signing under genuine duress can be grounds to challenge the agreement later.

There is no fixed formula — the amount depends on the strength of your legal claims, your salary and benefits, your length of service, and what the employer is willing to pay to achieve a clean resolution. A settlement agreement typically includes at least a redundancy payment or payment in lieu of notice, and often an additional ex gratia sum to reflect the value of the claims being waived. The stronger your legal position — for example, if you have a clear unfair dismissal or discrimination claim — the more leverage you have to negotiate. Taking legal advice before responding to an offer helps you assess whether what is on the table reflects the realistic value of your claims.

Not necessarily — employers offer settlement agreements for a wide range of reasons, including avoiding the cost and management time of tribunal proceedings, achieving a clean break, protecting confidential information, or as a standard part of a redundancy or restructuring process. An offer does not automatically signal that the employer believes it would lose at tribunal. That said, the terms on offer — particularly the financial amount — can reflect the employer's assessment of risk. Taking legal advice on the strength of your position before responding helps you distinguish between an offer that is genuinely generous and one that significantly undervalues your claims.

A settlement agreement can waive most employment law claims, including unfair dismissal, wrongful dismissal, discrimination, harassment, whistleblowing detriment, and breach of contract. However, it cannot waive certain claims regardless of what it says: personal injury claims where the employee was not aware of the injury at the time of signing; accrued pension rights; and claims relating to the agreement itself — for example, if the employer later breaches the settlement. The agreement must specifically identify the claims being waived — a blanket waiver of all claims is not sufficient. Your solicitor will check that the drafting is legally effective and flag any gaps or concerns before advising you to sign.

If your employer fails to comply with the terms of a signed settlement agreement — for example, by failing to make the agreed payment, providing a different reference than agreed, or breaching a confidentiality obligation — you can bring a claim for breach of contract in the civil courts or, in some circumstances, the employment tribunal. The settlement agreement itself is an enforceable contract. Signing a settlement agreement does not mean you have no further recourse — it waives your original employment claims but creates new contractual rights that are enforceable if breached. If your employer is in breach, take legal advice promptly on the best route to enforcement.

A settlement agreement is a legally binding contract between an employer and an employee that resolves disputes or ends employment on agreed terms. In exchange for a financial payment — and sometimes other benefits such as an agreed reference or extended notice — the employee agrees to waive specified legal claims against the employer. For a settlement agreement to be legally valid, the employee must receive independent legal advice from a qualified adviser before signing. Settlement agreements are used in a wide range of circumstances: redundancy, disciplinary proceedings, performance management, restructuring, and where an ongoing employment relationship has simply broken down. Once signed, the agreed claims cannot be pursued in the employment tribunal or courts.

Without prejudice is a legal principle that protects genuine settlement negotiations from being disclosed to a tribunal or court — conversations or correspondence marked without prejudice, made in a genuine attempt to settle a dispute, cannot generally be referred to in subsequent proceedings. Section 111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 provides a related but distinct protection for pre-termination negotiations — sometimes called protected conversations — which can be kept out of unfair dismissal proceedings even where there is no existing dispute. Neither protection is absolute: without prejudice communications can be disclosed where there is evidence of improper conduct, such as threats or undue pressure. If you are unsure whether a conversation is protected, take advice before responding.

An ex gratia payment is a payment made by an employer that the employee has no contractual entitlement to — it is paid as a goodwill gesture or in settlement of claims rather than in discharge of a contractual obligation. Genuine termination payments — including ex gratia payments — benefit from a £30,000 tax-free threshold: the first £30,000 of a qualifying termination payment is free from income tax and National Insurance. Payments above £30,000 are taxable. Not all payments in a settlement agreement qualify: payment in lieu of notice (PILON), holiday pay, and bonuses are taxable in full regardless of how they are labelled. Structuring the settlement correctly to maximise the tax-free element is an important part of the negotiation.

Have a question that isn't covered here? Speak to one of our settlement agreements specialists directly.

Get started with our settlement agreements team

Confidential, no pressure, and we'll explain what's involved before you commit to anything.